This is what I call receiving mixed messages. After regular doses of pestering, my mother finally drove me to Saint Benedict Center, where we enjoyed a Traditional Latin Mass on Sunday. Later on, we got a few goodies at their book store; I selected Father Leonard Feeney's The Bread of Life and Hilaire Belloc and Cecil Chesterton's The Party System [with a foreword by Ron Paul and an introduction by an Italian prince]! And as always, one of the most enjoyable parts was Brother André Marie, M.I.C.M. His subject this week was culture. With a comic's pity, Brother detailed the archetypical teenager of the anticulture, whose idea of a fancy meal is McDonald's, and whose cultural reference points are late night, sitcoms, "and if you're lucky, a 'classic' like The Three Stooges". Expectably, his outlook on life is that of a fool. To my dismay, but less so than it would have been were it not expected, he noted that while some art forms can be incorporated into an authentic Catholic culture (he mentioned folk music, and the general ease missionaries found in adapting traditional Japanese culture to the Faith- score 1 for my all-time favorite TV series, The Vision of Escaflowne), others could not: he mentioned video games (that's 1 down each for The Legend of Zelda: The Twilight Princess) and popular music played on the radio. Alas, what a jab at my beloved Sarah McLachlan, Nelly Furtado, Backstreet Boys, et al! True enough, they shall never find a place in local, community festivals, but can their music really be declared antithetical to Christianity unless it nearly always leads one to improper thoughts? It certainly has never had that effect on me.
And then there was this. The Diocese of Burgos is preparing the cause of beatification for Marta Obregon, a pious Spaniard who was killed resisting a sexual assailant in 1992. Her story is moving, and reminds me of the tragic tale of Saint Maria Goretti. Curiously, though, she was murdered on her way home from a night club [while this provided a segue to the discussion of pop culture, I have since learned that this was a mistake on the part of the news agency which was my source; please see the comments]. Canonized saints are models for Catholics in future ages to emulate; in light of Brother's words on pop music (and then, I would expect, the dancing that goes with it), this is quite a mixed message. The only other good Catholic partyer that comes to mind is Primo de Rivera, who once upon a time ran a brief but highly successful and Church-friendly moderate dictatorship in Spain- he was apparently quite wild during early military career, and yet he now lies alongside Francisco Franco in the Valley of the Fallen. Perhaps more troubling still, though, Marta Obregon was also a member of the Neocatechumenal Way, of which I have heard only bad words from my traditionalist surveys.
In light of this development, my fellows in Backstreet Boys fandom would be wise to set up a John Paul II-style canonization-process-that-begins-before-death for said group's Howard Dorough, who is very public about his Catholic faith- enough to open his own line of jewelry, available from Rock your Religion, with the proceeds going to battle Lupus.


9 Comments:
While I'm sure Brother has good intentions, it seems a bit too much to ask us to ignore all popular music (even those that do not lead us to improper thoughts or actions!)
I don't think that we Catholics should make ourselves cultural oddities. That seems like a sure way to distance us further from mainstream society.
Dear 19 years-old man, I have to make a small correction: Arlanza is not a nightclub, is a cultural association. Martha was there every day to study in preparation for their examinations of Journalism.
Please, take a look:
http://www.aytoburgos.es/contenidos/cpcontent.asp?contentid=29112&nodeid=30554
http://www.radioarlanzon.com/modules.php?name=News&file=print&sid=8011
I am sorry, but I cannot read the Spanish links. The story I have read and linked to called it the "Arlanza night club". Since you would probably not have pointed this out if you were not sure of the facts, and the cultural center likely does not also maintain a night club, I apologize for the error.
On the other hand, I can hardly believe the Catholic News Agency could have made such a big mistake!
Crusader88, I live in Burgos (Spain), near the "Cultural Association Arlanza" and I assure you the cultural center DOES NOT also maintain a night club. Please, correct you blog entry. The article you read in order to write your blog entry was a literal translation of an article written in Spanish. "Club" in Spanish doesn't mean "night club". "Club" translates as "association of people with a common goal".
Learning languages enriches people. And anyway, the Google translator is tremendously useful. You can't modify the original source if you want to became a good and reliable communicator.
Thanks for reading. Cheers!
PS: Archbishop of Burgos is already down to work to alert Catholic News Agency from the big mistake. Rectify is of wise people.
Yes, the Catholic News Agency does in fact make mistakes. Club Arlanza Burgos is not a nightclub, but rather a social and cultural organization, as Reader says.
One would wonder what else the Catholic News Agency may have gotten wrong . . .
I also don't think it is necessary to blanket absolutely EVERYTHING in pop culture to be immoral. There are plenty of music arists who have perfectly clean lyrics and topics. But, there are also a lot of artists who have very immoral themes in their music, or have clean music, but contribute their money to immoral charities.
I think, as Christians, we just need to be aware of the music that we are putting into our ears, to ensure that we are not subliminally subjecting ourselves to immorality, and make sure that the money we spend on these artists' albums and concert tickets aren't going towards anti-Christian funding.
Thank you for the correction! I have made note of my error in the original post. Please stop by again.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home